Wednesday, 22 January 2014

Anand Gandhi: Poor show by most professional courses

If there are images in this attachment, they will not be displayed.  Download the original attachment

 In conversation with Anand Gandhi...

On Indian education system
Our education system is not built on a solid and understanding foundation. The system has not comprehended the original meaning of education. By that statement, I mean that almost all professional courses in India have failed immensely. The graduates who pass out of their colleges at the end of their undergraduate courses know shockingly little about their profession and the same is the case with some postgraduate courses as well.
However, the statement is not a sweeping remark on everything, seeing that there are postgraduate courses that run quite well, but most of the postgraduate institutes do not provide the kind of students that they are expected to. The colleges in our country neither encourage students to assess and enquire new ideas nor do they allow them to examine new ideas and data. These are the skills that an educational institution should provide to its students, which, unfortunately, none of the institutes encourage.

Tackling the issue
It is a monster of a problem which can be resolved through two ways. A short-term objective could be for students to do something in this regard. Thankfully, students are now benefitted with means to an end. They can choose many courses that are available online. If you want to educate yourself without paying a single penny, even that facility is available through online courses which you can download and start studying.

If you find that your colleges do not stimulate you or encourage creativity, you could always turn to online courses. But you would have to be quite disciplined about it. The second and the long-term objective is one in which all of us come together for the betterment of the system. It can happen over a period of time. We have to come together as a community and identify the problems, articulate the issue, break it deconstruct it and then troubleshoot the problem

On well-informed people
I have come across only three types of well-informed people. The first category is from villages, including the hands-on Indians, who try new ways to repair their tractors and invent new ways to repair and reinstall something. They may not have the perfect book education, but their practical knowledge on the world is quite awe-inspiring. The second category includes those who have done an undergraduate course in India and then gone abroad for their higher studies. The third category is those who have done their education here.

PC: bolegaindia.com
Article first appeared in education Insider magazine


Neeta Lulla: Indian fashion industry set for big leap

 Neeta Lulla is one of the most popular and celebrated fashion designers in India. Neeta twirled into the fashion designing world about two decades ago. She started her career as the assistant choreographer of former choreographer Jeanne Naoraji n the late 1980s before starting her career in costume designing. She came into the limelight after bagging a National Film Award for designing ‘Roop Ki Rani’ Sridevi’s costume in the 1990 blockbuster movie Lamhe. Neeta won the National Film Award for Best Costume Design in 2009 and 2012 for Jodha Akbar and Balgandharava, respectively. Over the past 28 years, Neeta Lulla has worked for some of the finest Indian films and the biggest stars in Indian cinema. 
 
In conversation with Neeta Lulla...

As an expert in fashion industry, what is your opinion in taking fashion designing as a career?
I believe that fashion designing is a great career especially because of the growing awareness in fashion across all strata of income groups in our country. Fashion is segmented into various avenues that need fashion experts today to cater to the needs of the aware consumer and this profession is definitely going to grow multi-fold in the coming years.

What are the opportunities and hurdles before the youth in moulding a career in fashion industry?
I think there are two major hurdles that the youth face today. First, it is the technical expertise, which will help channelise them into the right segment of fashion. Second, it is the lack of corporate or financial backup.

When we consider the Indian fashion Industry, what are the opportunities here for a fashion designer?
Today, a fashion designer has tremendous opportunities as opposed to when I first started. The younger lot these days are really lucky as they are exposed to an environment that shows diversity in cultures and dressing sensibilities.

Could you mention the various branches that a youth can specialise in fashion industry?
Today, there are so many branches a student can choose to specialise in. Apart from designing, there are a number of other career options that students can explore – like pattern making, quality control, visual merchandising, marketing, illustration, styling, fashion photography, and fashion journalism.

What prevents the growth of the Indian fashion industry compared with the West?
Infrastructure backup is missing in India. Also, I feel we lack the right experts with experience in creative or backend support.

Could you define the role of fashion weeks in career development of a designer?
I believe a fashion week helps promote the business and gives an awareness of the creative sensibilities of the designer.

What is your opinion of the quality of fashion design education in India?
When I started out in the fashion industry, there were limited options available within fashion education in India, but today, the space is fast growing as more and more students are opting for this field. It also gives me great pride that my School of Fashion has begun and will train fashion aspirants to excel at the highest levels.

What are the qualities required for a good fashion designer?
I think that the biggest quality that is required to be a good fashion designer is dedication. One must be extremely dedicated to the profession, focused in life, have clear goals and keen observation skills.

How does an individual get started in the fashion industry?
Firstly, specialising in one’s skills, then working with the right platform in that expertise. If you are an entrepreneur, then it is working on a style identity from the first collection that is launched to create a brand.

What are your Top Ten tips for the aspiring fashion designers?
1.       Focus on education
2.       Read lots of books
3.       Observe the fashion happenings
4.       Research on fashion
5.       View shows
6.       Understand garment finishes
7.       Understand colour sensibilities
8.       Know your fabrics
9.       Create your own style statement
10.     Focus on your goals

PC: Neeta Lulla 
Article first appeared in the Education Insider magazine

Sashi Kumar: Cause and commitment should be your motto

 Sashi Kumar is a journalist, filmmaker and media thinker and initiator who launched Asianet TV channel and subsequently founded, and chairs, the not-for-profit public trust Media Development Foundation, which runs Asian College of Journalism. He started his career with Doordarshan as newsreader and producer. Later, he worked in PTI-TV as chief producer and general manager of PTI. Sashi Kumar has authored and presented independent programmes on economy, politics and culture on Indian television, like Money Matters, Tana Bana, and Jan Manch


In conversation with Sashi Kumar ...

In the age of new-media journalism, what do you think is the future of print media? Do you think the print media is declining?
Once the new media becomes full-fledged, print journalism will decline. In Western countries, a number of newspaper organisations have been shut down because of the growth of internet and new-media journalism. However, in India, this will happen only in a longer time. We have newspapers that are registering growth, as against the mature media market in the West. There has been a rise in the readers for regional-language newspapers. Literacy programmes are the reason for this phenomenon. I think it will take another 10-12 years for the new media to get domination in the country.

How is new media going to change the face of journalism?
Gone are the days when we had to wait for the morning newspapers. These days, we have the internet, and the information being provided in the internet is very vast. Media is categorised as print, visual, audio, etc. All these media culminate together in new media, where you can read, see, and listen, so the viewers or readers can experience everything. This is used to access information from anywhere and anytime. Interactive feature is another advantage that is worth mentioning about the new media, which allows people to exchange their ideas and views on a certain topic.

Newspaper organisations have to cut down trees to produce newsprint. Unlike newspaper, new media do not have any space restriction problems. Cyberspace is vast and infinite. The capsule format in which information is presented attracts the readers. New media is user-friendly and easily adaptable.
 
The big drawback of online journalism, according to many experts, is its financial viability. How can we integrate the digital media platform to make it financially viable?
When new media will become economically viable revenue model is a big question. So far, new media is not a revenue model; internationally there are few new media platforms like Financial Times, Huffington Post, ohmynews.com which can be taken as examples for revenue models. In the US, classified advertisements sites generate bigger revenues than news-related sites. News journalism sites as a revenue model is yet to be a fact.

What do you think the quality of present-day journalists?
I think there has been a bottoming out in the quality of present-day journalists. Another interesting fact is that the whole distinction between the profession called journalism and readers are blurring. The public itself has become the generators of news. Blogging, micro-blogging, social networking sites are the platforms for this. To evaluate the quality of journalists, it is not possible right now; we may be able to do it after 10- 15 years.

Does the mushrooming of journalism schools affect the quality of journalism?
Respectable journalism institutes have always helped in upgrading the quality of journalists. Until the late 1990s, we did not have a concept of journalism institutions; instead, we had mass communication courses. Universities in the country offered mass communication courses where different communication theories and public relations theories were taught. It was altogether a mishmash. It was in the late 1990s that the country saw the emergence of journalism institutes, whereas the Western countries had institutions which offered courses in journalism. I think that respectable journalism institutions produce better journalists.

On the one hand, the national dailies in English are losing ground. On the other, the vernacular Press is booming. What is your comment?
The national dailies are not losing ground, but the rate of growth is dipping. Their growth is marginal. About the booming of the vernacular Press, as said earlier, it is mainly because of the success of literacy programmes.

Do you think that journalism is a safe career? Or, does one choose the career as one’s commitment to society?
Journalism nowadays is a good career option. Earlier, people opted for journalism out of passion; money alone was not the sole intention. However, at present, this profession is a highly paid job. At the entry level itself, you are paid highly. Apart from this, it is an influential career.

PC: rediff.com, memeburn.com
Article first published in Education Insider magazine

Vasundhara Das: Believe in yourself

 According to me, education has a lot more to do with learning from life than from the classroom. I have learned more outside the classroom




In conversation with Vasundhara Das...


On school life
School life has not contributed much to my musical life. In those times, when I was in school, the education system did not encourage arts. Academics were considered as the end of everything. People thought that music cannot be opted as a career. Most of the parents were prejudiced about music and had an attitude that it cannot be taken as a profession, but my parents were an exception. At the age of 5, I started learning Hindustani music. I got intensive music education because my parents were very keen on making me learn music.

On college life
College contributed a great deal to my musical career. I was clear about going to that particular college (Mount Carmel College, Bengaluru) because that college had a good music association. I knew that the college would nurture my musical career.

I still remember the day when my Mom took me to the Engineering counselling. I was standing in the queue. When it was just two turns for my interview, I seemed restless to my Mom. When she asked me the reason, I told her that I don’t want to be an engineer. What surprised me was my Mom’s reaction; she told me that I could have said it before and that there was no point in wasting our time. We left the spot. That is a distinct memory for me.

In the college, I was the member of a choral group. We had a Western Music Association. I got the exposure of performing at various inter-college competitions. I won in many of them, and that gave me a lot of confidence and helped prepare my future.  I was very clear about music; that was what I wanted to do as long as I was alive.

Memories
Too many. I really had a ball. I enjoyed college than school. My first stage performance ever in college was during my first-year PUC. About 4,000 girls in the auditorium are booing you, because you are a junior. I started singing the song I love You, by Whitney Houston. There was pin-drop silence, and, once I finished singing, there was a huge round of applause by the entire audience. That is a memorable moment for me.


Click : Lakshmi
Article first appeared in education Insider Magazine



Rajdeep Sardesai: Journalist by accident

 Rajdeep Sardesai has been working as the editor-in-Chief of IBN18 Network, which includes CNN-IBN, IBN 7 and IBN Lokmat. He comes with 22 years of journalistic experience during which he has covered some of the biggest stories in India and the world. Prior to setting up the IBN network, he was the Managing Editor of both NDTV 24X7 and NDTV India and was responsible for overseeing the news policy for both the channels. He also worked with The Times of India for six years and was the city editor of its Mumbai edition at the age of 26


In conversation with  Rajdeep Sardesai...

You graduated from St Xavier’s and then you did your masters in LLB from Oxford .Why so?
See, teenage is a time when you don’t have any idea of what to do with life and career.  So the option left with me was to study. Graduation is something you really have to do and I was really interested in doing Master’s in Law, thinking that it has large options for career. And, above that, I liked the idea of arguing and debating. But, destiny kept something else for me, and I became a journalist. However, the training I received as a lawyer has helped me a lot in my career as a journalist.

You were never went to a journalism institute and was not a journalism student at all. How did you get into this field?
Writing always remained to be one of my passions and I always loved to write. During my graduation days, which were in mid-1980s, Behram Contractor started the newspaper Afternoon. The newspaper office was close to my college and one day I approached Behram and asked him whether I could help him with his work. He showed interest in me and I joined Afternoon as a trainee reporter.

After my graduation, I went to Oxford to do Master’s in Law and after coming back from there, I joined Crawford Bailey, a leading law firm, as a lawyer. After working there for a while, I wanted to take a break. At that time, there existed a tradition in Times of India: they offered a post for those who come from Oxford – Assistant Editor.  So I joined Times and continued there for another 6 years. So journalism was purely an accident in my life.

What about your transition from print-media journalist to television journalist?
The transition was a difficult one, but with the course of time, I got adapted to it.  Though print don’t pay as much TV does, I will go back to print journalism if given a chance. Even after so many years, I still feel that I am more comfortable with print media than the visual media.

What is your opinion on the relevance of journalism education?
Once Journalism and Mass Communication course was neglected by all, but these courses have a lot of demand among students these days. I think the boom in the visual media sector is the main reason for this mass demand. Journalism has become one of the most sought after course in the country.

Does new media democratise journalism?
Yes, the new media is acceptable to everybody. New media has become cheaper and affordable to everybody. Gadgets of new media are more and more affordable to the common people. Mobile phones available in the market have cameras with high resolution and the photographs and video clippings of many historic incidents like the tsunami were captured by ordinary citizens and they were the ones who passed the clippings to different TV stations and news media. So, in short, what am trying to tell is that the thin line between journalists and public is disappearing.

There is a strong criticism that TV journalism is not taking up issues in depth but is running after sensationalism. What is your comment?
We, as visual journalists, have a lot of pressure on us. I partly agree with that, but the scenario will change in the course of time.

Five tips to broadcasting journalists
§  Always be confident
§  Be a good communicator
§  Be honest to yourself
§  Be honest to the story you are doing
§  Always have the capability to distinguish between what is right and what is wrong

Message to aspiring journalists      

Chase your dreams, be loyal to your profession, don’t get carried away by anything. Changes are inevitable, get adapted to it. There is always room for improvement.


PC: edinburghnnapierjournalism.com
Article first appeared in the Education Insider magazine

Naresh Iyer: Down memory lane

 Celebrated Singer Naresh Iyer’s memoir on his student life





In conversation with Naresh Iyer...

Memories of school
School life played a huge role in my life. Sera Ma’am, my class teacher in Fifth Grade, was the one who identified the singer in me. I did my first stage performance during the same time. The most memorable moment in school life was my first stage performance at the school annual competition where I came first. The song I sang was Kaali Raam Ka Bajgaya Dhol from the movie Barsat Ki Ek Raat. The applause and appreciation received mattered a lot to the 12-year-old kid. Even after years, that moment stays etched in my heart. I have won many prizes and awards, including the National Award and the Filmfare Award, but nothing can replace the joy I experienced when I was 12 years old – when I was recognised as the best singer in my school.

Memories of college
During my college days, I participated in various inter-college festivals in Mumbai. I was eliminated in one of the college festivals during my first-year graduation. Though I was depressed at that time, it was that which helped me develop my God-given talent. Thereafter, I didn’t have to look back. I won in almost all the competitions in which I participated.

Apart from music, sports was another field of interest during my college days. I have participated in inter-college table tennis tournaments and various other tournaments and have won prizes.

One of the proudest moments in my graduation days was when I came topper in the foundation course in my second year.

While recalling the memories during the graduation days, one incident that rushes to my mind is the embarrassing moment which I have had during a musical show when I sang O Jane Jana totally out of pitch because my colleague had accidently played a wrong note.  Though at that time I really felt awkward, now it has become a reason for giggles and laughter.
As a student, I always made sure not to mix my academics with my extracurricular activities, and I scored more than distinction in all my examinations. I can proudly say that I was a good student. Life as a student was indeed a learning ground for me, which instilled in me courage, confidence and helped me live an optimistic life.

PC: Cinemapluz.in
Article first appeared in the Education Insider magazine




Rini Simon Khanna: Mere media degree doesn’t make a journalist

 Having worked with state-run Doordarshan as news anchor for 16 years, Rini Simon Khanna has become a household name in the country. In addition to presenting news, Rini is an experienced voice talent, rendering commentary and voiceovers for documentaries, advertisement films and feature films. She also anchors international and national conferences, cultural shows and seminars for prestigious organisations, UN agencies, corporate groups and government agencies

 In conversation with Rini Khanna...


Journalists then and now  
There are lot of differences between the journalists of yesteryears and journalists of today. I think technology has a big role in this. The truth is that people who are in the media are not definitely tech-savvy – a lot of us. Technologies change one’s ability. We have to be savvier with what we are doing and also savvy with the technologies that are available worldwide .There are lots of technologies which have changed the world. So people in the media have to be savvier with the technologies worldwide. One cannot say that ‘I was not aware of it.’ You have to be somebody who is connected all the time, you have to know the breaking news, best deals plus to be able to upload and send your reports. You can no longer say that you couldn’t file your story because you didn’t have a fax machine or connectivity. Definitely, technologies are the gamechanger today plus the input for information; you have twitter, face book, all the social media tools plus all kinds of information is coming from all kinds of media. Obviously, journalists of today are not just the ones who read some books and wrote stories some time. You have to be updated with everything happening around. You can’t afford to be out of the scene for any reason.

Quality of journalism students
The problem is not in the education part. The problem is that everything is ‘breaking news’ today. So, in the hurry to get that, you skip a lot of fact. You don’t have the time to go into anything in depth. How much attention do you give a particular story? If there is a ‘breaking story’ today, there might be five breaking stories at the same time. So, according to me, people who are doing reporting today don’t have the depth of knowledge that a senior journalist has. Their knowledge is very superficial and they don’t have the time for investigation, so they take any information they get. They are not ready to go back and check whether the information given is true or whether somebody is trying to mislead them with false information. The senior journalist has that many years of experience behind him; he also has that much of wisdom behind him. He has been able to analyse news, give it enough thought, was able to put it in the correct perspective, and was efficient enough to give other angles to the story.

Resolving the issue
The market will tackle it. It is like going to a bookshop – there are lots of books. There are books which are churned out in a minute, book by overnight authors, you have twitter authors. The audience knows what to pick up. They would pick up books which they take back home and sit in an armchair, give it a thought and read, or books that can be read in a flight journey when you can fling it out after reading. It depends on the audience. Right now, the audiences have 250 news channels to graze through. The same is the case with journals and other magazines. What do they choose out of this? Burning-out rate is on the rise – that is the reason why many channels and other media organisations are closing down. So unless your material is authentic and well-developed, you are not going to sustain.

Media institutes
In my days, there were no journalism institutes apart from Indian Institute of Mass Communication (IIMC), but things have changed now. We have different media institutes and universities offering media courses. The saddest part is that only few institutes are able to sustain. Again, the market decides which is better. Journalism is not like an essay written during your academics. In beat reporting, you should have an idea about crime, politics, law and many other things that are happening around. Each media institute caters to a particular audience. I don’t know about the quality of institutes because it is like comparing apples to oranges. Each institute has its own unique character.

Need for media institutes
Nobody has to be qualified to become a journalist. You can’t say that you are a surgeon after doing one operation; the same is with journalism. Your standard and quality is determined by how long you are able to sustain this. After all, this is an art. You can’t be just a writer and say that you are a journalist. There is so much to add to your skills. There is certain discipline that you need to follow in a media school. You are exposed to certain things which you may not be able to be exposed to. For instance, a common man will not be able to step into a studio and record or do a story or use a machine. You don’t necessarily have to be a part of a media institution to be able to become a journalist, but there is a certain sort of grounding that has to take place.

PC: caravanmagazine.in
Article first appeared in the 2013 December issue of Education Insider magazine

Shankar Tucker: In music, talent matters much

 Shankar Tucker is an American clarinettist and music composer. He rose to fame with the popularity of his online music series called The Shruti Box, which features his compositions. The Shruti Box was released online on platforms like YouTube and Soundcloud.

Shankar graduated from New England Conservatory in Boston, where he studied orchestral clarinet performance.

In conversation with Shankar  Tucker...


On Indian connection
I would say that Western music is often rigid, especially the classical traditions. Classical music is extremely rigid in the West. Indian classical music has built into it a kind of inherent improvisation. North Indian music and South Indian music absorb different influences like instruments such as violin, introduced here by the British during their rule. I have been completely taken by classical, traditional music. Western classical music is exactly the same as during the time of Beethoven.

On education
Education is learning and building your skills. For the world, when it comes to music, I am afraid institutional education, in a way, can take you to a point, but it can’t take you all the way in the same way medicine or other career paths can. In music, you feel like an entrepreneur. You have to consider yourself like a startup company or like a brand and you can’t depend on any sort of resume or piece of paper to help you with that. So it’s about skill – whether you learn from somebody else or teach yourself through hard work.

On student life

I graduated from New England Conservatory in Boston. As a student, I tried avoiding all sort of troubles. As I mentioned earlier, the tradition of Western music is very rigid.  When I was getting into Indian music, people, including my teachers, thought I was pretty weird. 

PC: shankartucker.com

The article first appeared in the 2013 December issue of Eduation Insider magazine

Ashish Khetan: New-age Indian media ignoring investigative journalism


Ashish Khetan is an investigative journalist who exposed the men behind the Gujarat massacre of 2002. He carried this brave sting operation over a six-month period, risking his life to bring the grisly facts to light.

In conversation with Ashish Khetan...

One year ago, Noam Chomsky opined that the Indian media was in great crisis. He even said the media in Pakistan was more vibrant than the Indian media. When it comes to ethics, where do the Indian media stand?

I would agree with the first part of Chomsky’s statement that the Indian media is in great crisis; it is in crisis in terms of its principles, ethics, values, what they do, priorities they have, their philosophy. Whichever way you look at the Indian media, you can see that there is a rapid decline, and it is going further down.

Only 1% of the population of this country is the super-elite, but they are controlling media ownership, news agenda and the Indian media caters to their interest and not to the interest of the 99% of the people of India. We have seen the recent episode involving Zee News and Naveen Jindal, where Zee News was caught extorting money to drop certain stories or to go soft on some stories against Jindal. Not carrying stories against their advertisers and equity holders is one thing; the media carrying untruthful stories in favour of their advertisers and their equity holders is another thing.

The electronic media, in particular, lack ethics – they jump into conclusions and carry stories without giving the other party the right to be heard. They are too judgemental, and there is a clear prejudice against the minorities, tribals and rural population .I think it goes on and on about the lack of ethics in Indian media, but these are some broad areas which are disturbing.

What are the challenges an investigative journalist has to face when compared to other streams of journalism? 
Investigative journalism is really challenging. When it comes to political reporting, a reporter is supposed to give a good analysis or a good perspective of a political situation or a political personality or has to identify political trends . What makes investigative journalism different from other aspects of journalism are the following:
1. You are trying to uncover something which others are trying to hide; this is the most difficult part. You have to alert some on some information and there are other set of people who have some vested interest on some particular issue. The administration and the establishment are working against you and they will create hurdles in your path by blocking the information.
2. There is a kind of disinterest among the new-age editors and new-age proprietors. They are no longer interested in time-consuming and resource-consuming news stories .They are more interested in two-minute-noodles journalism.
3. The threat of physical violence: The element of physical threat and the element of risk are high in this stream of journalism. We have often seen how investigative journalists in some states are treated – they have been targeted by the mining lobbies, and, at times, by the state as well.

What are the things that an investigative journalist should keep in mind?
1. Perseverance: You have to persevere and not give up because investigative stories are not easy to come by. It really requires hard work and perseverance.
2. Commitment: Once you have identified that there is a story, then you have to follow it to its logical conclusion
3. Hard work and time: You should be ready to go through volumes and volumes of documents and the willingness to meet as many people as you can, ready to put hard work and long hours.
4. Be transparent.
5. Feel for the poor.

What do you think of the quality of young journalists passing out of different media institutions in our country?
Journalism is one thing that cannot be taught in any institutions. You can never be taught to become a good investigative journalist – either you have it or not have it. However, media institutions help in laying the foundation for their future work. I don’t want to comment on the quality.

What is your advice to an aspiring investigative journalist?

You have to take this as a mission .If you just want name, fame and money, then I think you are on the wrong domain of journalism. If you see any wrong thing done against the marginalised, then you have to raise your voice for them. You should have fire in your belly to be the voice of the voiceless.


PC: gulail.com
Article first appeared in 2013 February issue of Education Insider magazine

Tuesday, 21 January 2014

Atul Kulkarni: Exam shouldn’t be sole criterion


Atul Kulkarni is one of the brilliant actors India has ever seen and belongs to the list of those specialist character-actors like Nazarudheen Shah, Nassar, and Ompuri.

In a  conversation with Atul Kulkarni...


According to me, education is something that helps us stay in a group without troubling others. It helps in the inclusive development of an individual. Education will help you to improve yourself mentally and it will empower you in all possible ways.

I didn’t have a good experience during my days as a student. You might think it was because of the teachers or school authorities. No. That was not the reason; it was only because of the system.

On education system
The education system in India should be reinvented. See, our system of education is choosing the best student from a very large number of students, which should be changed. A good education system should be able to inculcate values in the students and should be able to find the best in every student.

All the educational institutions, starting from the kindergarten to professional colleges, are money-oriented and job-oriented. It is a sad fact. Another truth that disturbs me is that our system is churning out a group of selfish citizens.

As an actor, I feel that creativity is an integral factor in a person’s development. Generally, today’s student community lacks that. The student community of today lacks self-thinking, which is one of the biggest threats to creativity. Students are not able to make sensible decisions on their own; our education system should be blamed for that.

On examinations
We have a very wrong way of labelling students – ‘examinations.’  It is the only criterion in India to measure the intelligence and knowledge of a student. It is so senseless; a student who can remember, during the examination, the things he has studied and who scores 90-plus marks is declared to be a brilliant student. It doesn’t make any sense, at least to me.

On memories
You can’t be choosy, and it is actually not possible to recall memories in your life. I said earlier that my life as a student was a failure and I am the only one responsible for that because I was not able to cope with the system. In my junior class, I did a play and got wide recognition for that; it was my first success as an actor. To me, life is a process; it has nothing to do with your happiness, sadness, or failure.

PC: en.mediamass.net
Article first appeared in 2013 September issue of Education Insider magazine

Devdutta Patnaik: The king of sutras


All of us are familiar with designations like Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, and Chief Technical Officer. But has anyone ever heard of a designation called Chief Belief Officer (CBO)? Well, there is such a post, and it’s the first of its kind in the corporate world. Dr Devdutta Patnaik holds this post at Future Group, one of India’s retail pioneers with multiple retail formats. 

A physician-turned-leadership consultant, Dr Patnaik is an author whose works focus largely on mythology and management. He has written a number of books related to Hindu mythology, including Myth = Mithya: A Handbook of Hindu Mythology, The Pregnant King, and Jaya: An Illustrated Retelling of the Mahabharata.

When I entered the conference hall of Le Meridian, Cochin, to attend the Indian Association of Tour Operators (IATO) conference, I could hear the cackles of about 250 delegates present there. Since I knew none from the travel and tour industry, I thought it would be better to keep a close ear on the key note addresses. That’s when I found a plump person clad in a maroon silk shirt and smart pair of pants on the dais. To my astonishment, this gentleman turned out to be the CBO of Future Group, with whom I had an appointment.
I regretted being late for the session, but there’s nothing more I could do than curse the city’s heavy traffic for my delay. Dr Patnaik seemed very radiant and patient enough to answer the questions posed by the audience. Each answer by him was welcomed with a loud applause and laughter. Later, when I approached him for an interview, he welcomed me with a sunny smile.


In conversation with Devdutt Patnaik...

The journey thus far
I was a doctor by profession and spent about 15 years in the pharmaceutical industry. I have worked for Apollo Health Street and Sanofi Aventis. Then, I joined Ernst&Young as their Business Advisor. Since mythology was always a passion for me, I used to write articles related to it. In due course, I met Kishore Biyani of the Future Group, and he motivated me to turn my hobby into a profession.

Role as a CBO
CBO is just a designation created to excite people. It has been created to make people question the role of belief in menacing situations. Modern management is actually a Western belief, and will such a belief work in India? My theory is that it will not. The more you try to push Western beliefs in India, the more troubles you will have to face. Now, look at our judicial system, political system, and economic model. They are all Western. We are not adapting to it. We have not understood it well enough in order to adapt to it. We have not understood India or the West well and what we are doing is some strange ‘khichdi’ (mixture). This creates much more trouble than we can imagine because we are rejecting everything that is Indian. We have to discover who we really are. Rediscover. That’s the key point.

Mythology and modern management
The real question is how do we define mythology? It is a collection of stories, symbols, and rituals that communicates a subjective truth. Every culture has its own myth. This acts as an imperceptible force that influences decision-making, which is the axiom of modern management. Hence it is difficult to ignore myths. The only way to understand culture is through mythology.  
Whatever I believe, I communicate to others. What we call management today is based on the mythology of the West. People don’t realise it, but it is very obvious to a student of mythology. So, my question is if the mythology of the West can create management strategies, then why can’t Indian mythology do the same? It is a different way of looking at the same thing.

Medicine and mythology
Medicine is all about evidence, and mythology is about faith. That is the fundamental difference. In medicine, one needs evidence to believe in something, but when it comes to mythology, it is all about beliefs. Let us take an example of profit. If you think that profits are good for you, and you need to prove that, it is medicine. If you don’t care for a proof that profits are good for you, then it is mythology.

The connection between relationship and business
How do you manage your home? It is the same way we manage our society. If you think that you have to manage society differently from home, then you are wrong. We are being taught that it is different. There is no difference between managing our family and managing our business. Both have investments and returns. An individual getting married is expecting something from his/her spouse. You give something because you expect something in return from your partner, and if you don’t get anything, you are sad and depressed. A relationship is not so different from business. In business, you invest money, and in a relationship, you invest emotions. In Sanskrit, principles are called ‘tatva’. They won’t change. Same is the case with the principles in business too. The very same principle applies to day to day life also. In the West, they have made these divisions, of professional and personal life. According to me, such divisions are artificial.

Favourite mythological character
Lord Ram of the Ramayana. I don’t understand why everybody finds it great in criticising. Some wonder why our ancestors worshipped him as king. I couldn’t find an answer for it. Either our ancestors were wrong, or we are missing a very reflective fact.

About ‘Business Sutra’
As I said earlier, modern management is based on Western mythology, especially Greek and biblical mythology. The book ‘Business Sutra’ makes this obvious. It basically explores the ideas related to wealth generation, wealth management, and people management through stories found in Hinduism, Jainism, and Buddhism. We can learn a lot from these stories, which are being discussed in this book. There are 145 sutras in the book. We have a notion that business is only about wealth. It is a partial truth. Business is also about identity and wisdom.

Ten sutras for a happy mind at workplace

·       You should know that happiness is a combination of Lakshmi (material wealth), Saraswati (intellectual wealth), and Durga (emotional wealth), abbreviated as LSD. If there is no balanced exchange of all three, then happiness wouldn’t exist.
·         You should understand that beliefs cannot be measured, but they shape the way we think, the way we behave, and the way we do business. It is the base of everything.
·         Don’t assume that a decision is balanced; it is the greatest mistake of modern management. You should know that all decisions are influenced by the invisible belief systems of an individual.
·         Know that people want you to look at them: look at the person, not human resources, or people.
  • Be aware of the fact that all things are subjective - what is right in one situation may not be in another.
  • Know that Lakshmi chases the secure Vishnu while the insecure Indra chases Lakshmi; wealth follows confidence, confidence does not follow wealth.
  • Remember always that Lakshmi always comes with Alakshmi, the goddess of quarrels - so when there is wealth and fortune, fights are sure to follow.
  • Don’t forget that humans are 99 per cent animals, fearing scarcity and predators that they sense in their imagination.
  • Very well remember a small fact that everyone wants to feel significant in an organisation - systems and processes tend to dehumanise people and take away their relative significance.
  • Know that people often do not know why they are doing what they doing. This ignorance leads to confusion, hence unhappiness.


Message to youth      
I don’t believe in messages. Today’s youth have so many things to worry about. They don’t need one man telling them what to do and what not to do.




Click: Jose Jacob
Article first appeared in 2013 September issue of Money Indices magazine